Manchester United's narrow 1-0 victory over Everton on November 24, 2025, showcased a ruthless tactical discipline that has become Carrick's trademark. With Everton sitting eighth and Manchester United in fourth, this was a must-win for both sides. United's victory was secured through a combination of defensive solidity and clinical finishing, a stark contrast to Everton's recent struggles at home.

The Match: A Narrow but Decisive Victory

The match at Old Trafford was a tightly contested affair, with both teams creating chances but United's defensive resilience ultimately proving decisive. Everton's recent form had been a cause for concern, with only one win in their last eight home games. In contrast, Manchester United had been impressive under Michael Carrick, with four wins and a draw in their last five matches.

This victory was particularly significant given Everton's recent 1-2 defeat against Bournemouth and Manchester United's 1-1 draw against West Ham. United's ability to secure all three points against a resilient Everton side highlighted their tactical acumen and mental strength.

Tactical Analysis: United's Defensive Masterclass

Manchester United's tactical approach was built on a solid defensive foundation. With injuries to Patrick Dorgu, Matthijs De Ligt, and Mason Mount, Carrick had to make strategic adjustments. The 4-2-3-1 formation provided the necessary balance, allowing United to control the midfield and limit Everton's attacking options.

Everton, on the other hand, struggled to break down United's defense. Their recent form had seen them concede in six consecutive games, and this trend continued. Despite scoring in their last five matches, Everton's attacking prowess was neutralized by United's defensive organization.

The absence of Jack Grealish and Jake O'Brien due to injury and suspension respectively, further hampered Everton's attacking options. United's ability to contain Everton's forwards and capitalize on counter-attacks was a testament to their tactical discipline.

Key Performers: Fernandes and Branthwaite Shine

Bruno Fernandes was once again a standout performer for Manchester United. With six goals and twelve assists to his name, Fernandes' influence on the pitch was evident. His ability to dictate play and create chances was crucial in United's victory.

Jarrad Branthwaite's return to Everton in late January 2026 was a significant boost for the team. However, despite his presence, Everton's defensive struggles continued. Branthwaite's return did little to alter the defensive frailties that have plagued Everton in recent matches.

The Manager's Perspective: Carrick's Tactical Acumen

Michael Carrick's tactical decisions were pivotal in United's victory. His ability to adapt to the absence of key players and maintain defensive solidity was impressive. Carrick's recent form had earned him the Premier League Manager of the Month award, and this victory further cemented his reputation as a tactical mastermind.

David Moyes, on the other hand, faced a tough challenge in managing Everton's defensive issues. Despite his extensive experience and past success with Manchester United, Moyes struggled to find solutions to Everton's defensive woes. The 1-0 defeat highlighted the need for tactical adjustments and possibly new signings to bolster the defense.

What This Means for the Table

Manchester United's victory moved them to fourth place in the Premier League with 45 points. This crucial win kept them in contention for a top-four finish, a significant achievement given their recent struggles. The victory also highlighted their ability to perform under pressure and secure vital points in tight matches.

Everton, sitting eighth with 37 points, will need to address their defensive issues if they are to climb the table. Their recent form has been a cause for concern, and the defeat to Manchester United underscored the need for improvement. The return of key players and tactical adjustments will be crucial in their quest to secure a higher finish in the league.

Looking Ahead: The Road to the Top

As the season progresses, Manchester United will look to build on this victory and maintain their momentum. With a strong defensive record and clinical finishing, they are well-positioned to challenge for a top-four finish. The upcoming matches will be crucial in determining their final standing.

Everton, meanwhile, will need to address their defensive frailties and improve their home form. The return of key players and tactical adjustments will be essential in their quest to secure a higher finish in the Premier League. The defeat to Manchester United serves as a wake-up call, highlighting the areas that need improvement.

The tactical battle between Carrick and Moyes will continue to be a fascinating subplot in the Premier League. Both managers have shown their tactical acumen, and their ability to adapt and innovate will be crucial in the coming matches.